Economist reviews shocks to beef industry with implications for cattle, beef prices ahead
K-State’s Tonsor spoke at virtual K-State Risk & Profit Conference
MANHATTAN, Kan. – The beef cattle industry has already experienced three big “shocks” this year and the effects are ongoing, but have been blunted to some extent, according to a Kansas State University agricultural economist.
The first jolt came in mid-March when the COVID-19 pandemic
sparked stay-at-home orders in most states.
“That had big implications for food consumption,” said Glynn
Tonsor, a livestock market specialist with K-State Research and Extension.
Those implications included restaurant and school closures – two large outlets
for U.S. beef. As that happened, demand for beef shifted to grocery stores
which were allowed to stay open. The actions disrupted the long-established
flow of the beef supply chain.
The second shock happened soon after when clusters of COVID-19
cases began cropping up among employees in meat processing facilities, forcing
some to shut down temporarily to control the spread of the virus, said Tonsor,
presenting his Beef Cattle Outlook at the recent virtual 2020 K-State Risk
& Profit Conference.
That left market-ready cattle and other livestock in some areas
with no market to go to. The effect was a bottleneck, with a backlog of
market-ready animals growing for a time, but fewer processing facilities to
handle them. Tonsor estimated that cattle and hog processing dropped by as much
as 40% during the spring.
As that bottleneck was developing, so too were disruptions to
export channels, which have become increasingly important to the beef industry
in recent years. The worst of the “pinch point,” Tonsor said, was the last week
Though some characterized that time as a developing meat shortage,
Tonsor said that’s not accurate: “There was no shortage of animals. There was a
disruption in the flow and at times the variety of products that consumers
could get. But for the calendar year, we not only expect beef production to be
higher, but also domestic beef consumption to be up.”
The third shock stemmed from the first two. When consumers knew
they would be staying at home and limited in their movements and also learned
of meat processing slowdowns, some bought up large quantities of beef and other
food and goods, which was characterized as a hoarding situation.
“The shift to more at-home consumption highlighted that not all
meat is equal,” Tonsor said, noting that demand for ground beef products
strengthened while demand for steaks and related cuts – those normally sold to
restaurants – weakened.
Despite disruptions to beef exports, overall international trade
has helped temper the negative effects of the pandemic on the U.S. beef
industry, Tonsor said, warning that a growing protectionism sentiment in the
United States will work against the marketing of beef exports.
As of June 1, Tonsor said there were about 1 million head of
cattle backed up in the supply chain because of packing plant closures and
marketing chain disruptions. By Labor Day, however, he believes much of the
backlog will be processed.
“We’re getting much more current,” he said, but cautioned, “these plants have been running quite hard. We can’t take labor availability for granted. I don’t anticipate another situation where we have a 40% decline in production like we did in April, but we could still have some dips.”
He shared the most recent live cattle price outlook released by the Livestock Marketing Information Center which estimated the average slaughter steer price for the third quarter this year at $99 to $102 per hundredweight (cwt), which would be down 7.1% from a year ago.
Fourth quarter prices are expected to average $108 to $112 per cwt, down 7.5% from a year earlier, partly owing to heavier cattle and more beef as a result of working through the backlog. The overall average price for 2020 was estimated at $107 to $109, a decrease of 7.5% from 2019.
LMIC projections for next year indicate an increase in prices, with first quarter 2021 steer prices averaging $113 to $118; second quarter averaging $116 to $122; third quarter at $114 to $121 and fourth quarter at $117 to $125. Prices for 2021 overall were estimated at $117-$120, which would be 9.7% higher than 2020.